Best Pizza Places in Marathon, FL

Are you looking for the best pizza in Marathon? Is your stomach growling just thinking about a hot, cheesy slice of heaven? Look no further! We have rounded up the top spots to get your carb-loading fix on this beautiful island.

Although Marathon is typically known for its amazing seafood restaurants, it also has its fair share of excellent pizza options. Whether you’re searching for traditional New York-style thin crust, Chicago deep dish pies, or Neapolitan wood-fired pizzas – Marathon has something for everyone’s taste buds!

From craft brew tap rooms serving slices to tucked-away family-owned pizza spots with generational recipes, we have all of your go-to favorites, and some hidden gems are thrown into the mix. So what are you waiting for?

Let’s dig in and find out who is serving up the yummiest slices of ‘za on these sandy shores!

Paradise Cuban Restaurant

Photo Credit: Karyn Christner via Flickr CC2.0

• Address: 2603 Overseas Hwy
• Website: jpccr.com/
• $

If you’re looking for a no-frills, beach shack kind of pizza joint that won’t break the bank, look no further than Paradise Cuban Restaurant. While their Cuban classics are well known, they also make a great pizza pie.

They serve breakfast and lunch, boasting the best Cuban food on the island.

It should go without saying, but you’ve got to try the specialties such as the Shrimp Cuban Pizza or the Lobster Pizza. Yum! Order your dinner pizzas in advance, or try Paradise Cuban for lunch, as they close at 4:00 PM daily (2:00 PM on Sundays).

Driftwood Pizza & Subs

Photo Credit: Driftwood Pizza, Pasta, & Subs

• Address: 10875 Overseas Hwy, #140
• Website: driftwoodpizzaandsubs.com/
• $$

With fast and friendly service, delicious pies, plenty of other dishes from which to choose, and a relaxed atmosphere, what else could you ask for in a pizza place? Driftwood Pizza, Pasta, & Subs is one of the premier places to grab a pizza in Marathon, FL.

For an innovative take on an Italian classic, try the Spaghetti and Meatballs pizza! For something more traditional, we love the Driftwood Special (similar to a Pizza Supreme). If someone you’re vacationing with doesn’t feel like pizza, no problem! They offer everything from pasta and sandwiches to breadsticks and fast food-style apps.

Upper Crust Pizza

Photo Credit: snowpea&bokchoi via Flickr CC 2.0

• Address: 3740 Overseas Hwy
• Website: facebook.com/UpperCrustPizzaMarathon
• $$

Upper Crust Pizza is one of the flagship pizza restaurants in town and among the best pizza in Marathon. In addition to your standard pizza menu, Upper Crust also offers plenty of salads, pasta, Italian-style dinner entrees, and more.

Our pizza pick from Upper Crust is definitely the Tuscan - chicken, bacon, alfredo sauce, tomatoes, spinach, onions, and parmesan. They also have an extensive list of toppings if you want to build your own pizza.

Triton Seafood Restaurant

Photo Credit: Triton Seafood Restaurant Italian Cuisine & Pizza

• Address: 11399 Overseas Hwy, #123
• Website: tritonseafoodrestaurant.com/
• $$

Serving up a myriad of fried seafood and Italian cuisine, Triton seafood restaurant probably wouldn’t be the first place to come to mind when thinking of the best pizza in Marathon, FL. However, you’d be remiss to skip over this one!

Try the Conch Fra Diavolo Pizza, a spicy seafood pie for something unique. Traditionalists will love their Pizza Supreme, complete with all the standard toppings and more.

Blu Bistro

Photo Credit: Blu Bistro

• Address: 19 Sombrero Boulevard
• Website: skipjackresortmarathon.com/
• $$

Situated in Skipjack Resort Marina, Blu Bistro was formerly known as Boot Key Bar & Grill. This on-site hotel restaurant offers plenty of different types of dishes, but we’re here for the pizza. With a deliciously crispy golden crust and plenty of toppings to choose from, you can’t go wrong.

Being located in a hotel, the prices tend to be a bit on the higher side. However, we think the Blu Bistro is well worth the splurge.

Sparky’s Landing

Photo Credit: Sparky's Landing - Fish n Cocktails

• Address: 13205 Overseas Hwy
• Website: sparkyslanding.com
• $$

This relaxed, boho-style waterside restaurant has plenty on the menu to suit all tastes. It is also known as one of Marathon’s best bars! From BBQ chicken to gluten-free fish tacos, Sparky’s has it all. But their wood-fired pizzas are what really drive the crowds to this small hangout, especially on nights with live music.

Their pizza menu is innovative and creative, offering such pies as Shrimp and Bacon or Double Garlic (both of which are to die for!).

Tito’s Stop

Photo Credit: Tito’s Stop

• Address: 10694 Overseas Hwy
• $$

This newly opened Marathon-infused pizza joint is small in size but mighty in taste. The menu at Tito’s is teeny-tiny, with only a small marker board listing the daily menu. That being said, their pizza offerings can change. Still, they usually offer a Build-Your-Own pizza option for a reasonable price and a selection of seafood, including lobster and ceviche.

When they do offer specialty pizzas, they often include creative options such as Ceviche Pizza or Tito’s Pizza con Todo.

Marathon Grill & Ale House

Photo Credit: Marathon Grill & Ale House

• Address: 5800 Overseas Hwy, #12
• Website: marathongrillandalehouse.com/
• $$

Described as “your hometown restaurant in the Keys,” Marathon Grill & Ale House brings the pizza in a big way alongside over forty choices for Micro Brew Beers.

They aim to please with a build-your-own option, including plenty of toppings to choose from! Pepperoni and olives? A DIY Hawaiian? The possibilities are endless. In addition, if you aren’t feeling pizza, they have Prime Rib Fridays and a host of seafood mains on offer as well.

7 Mile Pizzeria

Photo Credit: 7 Mile Cuban Restaurant

• Address: 2211 Overseas Hwy
• Website: 7milerestaurant.com/
• $$

If you thought Marathon Grill & Ale House had a limited pizza menu, wait till you get to 7 Mile Restaurant and Pizzeria - they only offer DIY pizzas! This allows for the ultimate test of creativity. The toppings they offer include chicken, pepperoni, meatballs, jalapenos, black olives, and picadillo.

Despite the seemingly limited options, their pizza is consistently ranked among the best in Marathon.

Coast to Coast Pizza Company $$

Photo Credit: Coast To Coast Pizza Company

• Address: 61 53rd Street
• Website: coasttocoastpizzacompany.com/
• $$

If you’re after New York-style pizza with a Florida Keys vibe, look no further than Coast to Coast Pizza Company. This is the spot to try some Neapolitan-style pies and innovative creations!

These guys are serious about pizza - recently, when they closed due to renovation, three of their pizza cooks became officially certified in the art of Italian pizza, going straight to Napoli to study the art of pizza making further in-depth. We assure you, you won’t want to miss this gem.

Papa John’s Pizza

Photo Credit: #FoodTograpiya | PauLRivera Photography via Flickr CC2.0

• Address: 5105 Overseas Hwy
• Website: papajohns.com/
• $

Sometimes, even the most serious pizza enthusiasts can enjoy a deliciously cheesy pizza from a national chain - particularly when it comes alongside some of Papa John’s infamous garlic sauce and pepperoncini!

In addition to pizza, you can find wings, salads, and other sides and apps here, such as mozzarella sticks.

Marathon Has Pizza and More

After reading this post, you should have a pretty good idea of where to go the next time you're in the mood for some delicious pizza in this part of the Keys.

There is so much to explore in Marathon between bites of pizza. Coco Plum Vacation Rentals has you covered for places to stay nearby one of your favorite pizza joints!